Control circuits and auxiliary circuits

The increasing demands on machines and installations in terms of operational safety and accident prevention require comprehensive measures to protect both man and machine. For example, insulation faults in a control system must not lead to hazardous machine motions. Therefore, when choosing a system type (TN, TT or IT systems) and the associated protective measures, the following aspects are of particular importance:

  • Probability of insulation faults
  • Necessary basic protection and fault protection
  • Continuity of the power supply
  • Technical and commercial aspects
  • Experience regarding secondary effects (fire, downtime costs, etc.)

In the case of electrical machines, this applies to the control circuits and auxiliary circuits as well as to the main circuits. In main circuits, the most important aspects are protection against electric shock, protection of persons and fire prevention. In control circuits and auxiliary circuits, especially those with voltages below the permissible touch voltage of AC 50 V/DC 120 V, the focus is on operational safety.

Control circuits - earthed or unearthed?

According to DIN EN 60204-1/VDE 0113-1, earth faults in control circuits must not lead to unintended start-ups or hazardous machine motions and they must not prevent the machine from shutting down. Generally, control circuits are supplied via an isolating transformer with separate windings or a separate power supply unit, considering that the secondary voltage must not exceed 50 V. The control circuit itself may be operated as an earthed system (TN system) or an unearthed system (IT system). However, unknown high-resistance insulation faults may cause controller faults, especially in the sensitive components of a control circuit. In an earthed system, these faults are not detected by a fuse since the fault current is too low to trigger the fuse. If the insulation fault has a low resistance, the fuse trips and the installation stops. To avoid this, control circuits are operated in unearthed systems and monitored via an insulation monitoring device.

More operational safety, even in the event of symmetrical insulation faults

Due to dirt, dust or moisture e.g. on limit switches, symmetrical insulation faults may occur in control circuits, which may then prevent the installation from being shut down or cause uncontrolled start-ups. Symmetrical insulation faults are resistive faults of the insulation of an electrical installation or device where all line conductors have approximately the same resistance to earth.

In this case, two high-resistance insulation faults on sensitive control inputs are enough to "set" the input. These faults do not cause the overcurrent protective device to trip since the fault current is noticeably below the required short-circuit current. Residual current devices also can't help since the forward and reverse currents are identical and therefore no residual current is generated. When selecting the corresponding insulation monitoring device it should be ensured that it is capable of detecting symmetrical insulation faults. Earth fault relays that measure the displacement voltage to earth as an evaluation criterion do not fulfil this requirement from a measuring principle point of view.

Conclusion

A standard-compliant version of control circuits does not necessarily have to be earthed. Especially when considering the aspects of operational safety, failure prevention and cost reduction, unearthed control circuits with insulation monitoring are often the better choice. Insulation fault location systems can be used as a complement to indicate where the insulation fault is located during operation. Which measure is finally taken has to be determined within a risk analysis.